Why Your Clinic’s SEO Isn’t Working (and How to Fix It)

You’re blogging, posting, optimizing your website, and doing “all the right things,” but your phone isn’t ringing as often as it should — or your website traffic just isn’t growing the way you expected.

If that sounds familiar, you might be wondering: How do I know if my SEO plan is actually working?

Let’s break it down.

Search engine optimization (SEO) isn’t just about increasing traffic — it’s about attracting qualified leads and new patient appointments. Unfortunately, many clinics waste months (and money) thinking SEO simply “takes time,” when the real problem is a broken strategy, not a lack of patience.


Podcast - Why Your Clinic’s SEO Isn’t Working (and How to Fix It)

Listen on...

Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts
Spotify
Stitcher
Amazon Music


Here are 10 common red flags that your SEO plan isn’t working — and what you can do to fix them.


1. Your Messaging Doesn’t Match Your Target Audience

Your “ideal patients” — the people you want walking through your door — should see themselves reflected in your website content and visuals.

If your messaging or images don’t align with who you’re trying to reach, that’s a major disconnect. For example, if your clinic mainly serves people who aren’t very active, but your website is filled with fitness-inspired imagery, you’re missing the mark.

Fix it: Clearly define your target audience. Then, review your website, social media, and marketing materials to ensure they reflect that audience’s lifestyle, needs, and language.


2. You Can’t Find Your Business on Google

If your website doesn’t appear when you search for your business name or related keywords, there may be a technical problem.

A common culprit? Your site might not be indexed by Google — meaning Google can’t “see” it. This is especially common for new websites or poorly configured site settings.

Fix it: Check your indexing status in Google Search Console. If you’re not sure how to do this, ask your web developer or SEO specialist to ensure your site is indexed correctly.


3. Your Website Traffic Isn’t Growing

Flat or declining traffic trends are a clear signal that something’s off.

You should be using Google Analytics (or another analytics tool) to track performance month over month and year over year. If you’re not seeing steady growth — or at least recovering from seasonal dips — it’s time to review your strategy.

Fix it:

  • Check which keywords you’re ranking for.
  • Audit your content quality — short, AI-generated, or duplicated content won’t perform well.
  • Don’t rely on “SEO-friendly” website settings alone; make sure your meta title tags and descriptions are custom-optimized.
  • Review your site on mobile to confirm that it loads quickly and looks professional.


4. You’re Getting Traffic, but No New Patients

Lots of visitors but no bookings? That usually means you’re attracting the wrong kind of traffic.

Maybe you published a blog post that went viral for the wrong reasons — perhaps it was trendy or loosely related to your services. If visitors aren’t potential patients, that traffic doesn’t matter.

Fix it: Focus on local, service-related, and condition-specific keywords. Then, review your calls to action (CTAs) — make sure it’s easy and obvious for visitors to book an appointment or contact your clinic.


5. You’re Ranking for the Wrong Pages

Sometimes, a blog post or page that wasn’t meant to rank ends up dominating your traffic — and not in a good way.

For instance, one clinic had a blog post titled something like “Why Chiropractic Care Might Not Be Right for You.” It generated tons of clicks but attracted skeptics, not patients.

Fix it: Audit your keyword rankings. Ensure your core service and condition pages rank higher than blog posts that aren’t conversion-focused. Update or re-optimize pages that pull in the wrong audience.


6. Your Content Is Outdated — or Too Reliant on AI

If you haven’t updated your website content in months (or if you’ve leaned too heavily on AI tools or “canned” content), your SEO results can quickly stall.

Google prioritizes fresh, original, and human-authored content. Overly generic or repetitive copy won’t help your rankings — and might even hurt them after an algorithm update.

Fix it: Regularly refresh your service pages and blog content. If you’ve used AI tools, humanize that content with your expertise, real examples, and local relevance.


7. You’re Not Tracking Your Progress

Without analytics, you’re flying blind.

If you don’t have Google Analytics or another tracking tool in place, it’s impossible to know what’s working and what’s not.

Fix it:

  • Set up Google Analytics 4 (GA4) to monitor organic traffic and conversions.
  • If GA4 feels overwhelming, try Clicky — it’s a simpler analytics option that provides an easy-to-understand dashboard.


8. Your Google Business Profile Isn’t Growing

Your Google Business Profile (GBP) powers your Google Maps visibility — and it needs regular updates to perform well.

If you’re not seeing growth in profile views, calls, or reviews, that’s a red flag.

Fix it:

  • Post weekly updates.
  • Add new photos.
  • Encourage and respond to reviews.
  • Track your performance using GBP Insights.


9. You’re Ignoring Other Online Listings

Many clinics focus solely on Google, forgetting other key listings like Apple Maps, Bing Places, or Yelp.

These citations build local authority and help Google confirm your business’s legitimacy and consistency.

Fix it:
Ensure your NAP (Name, Address, and Phone number) is consistent across all listings. Expand your reach by claiming and updating your profiles on other major platforms.


10. Your SEO Strategy Operates in a Vacuum

If your SEO efforts are disconnected from your broader marketing activities, you’re missing opportunities.

Your SEO strategy should complement everything else — your social media, email campaigns, community partnerships, and referral programs.

Fix it: Promote your optimized content across all channels. Share your blogs in emails, highlight them on social media, and build links from local community websites.


Next Steps

If you spotted even one or two of these red flags, you’re not alone — most clinics have at least a few areas to improve.

The good news: fixing SEO doesn’t mean starting from scratch. It’s about refining your strategy so your website attracts the right patients, not just more traffic.

If you want expert eyes on your SEO plan, visit Propel Marketing & Design to book a discovery call or explore free resources to help your clinic rank higher and grow faster.


Related Resources: 


Get our next podcast episode delivered directly to your inbox: 

We'll email you when we release new episodes.